Can you feel it coming? The election, then the holidays, complicated conversations at work and then at the table, where the gravy isn't the only thing running hot.
My cousin and I sit on opposite ends of one political issue. For years, our conversations ended the same way. Voices up, then the white flag: "We'll just have to agree to disagree." Polite. Final. Unhelpful.
Last time it came up, at a family barbecue in the backyard, I tried one sentence. "Let's start with what we agree on." It took about a minute to find it. We both care deeply about freedom. We ended up talking for a long time about what freedom means to each of us. We never circled back to the issue. Didn't need to.
Start with the value. The issue can wait.
Speak to the value under the issue
Every political opinion sits on top of something the person is protecting. Safety. Fairness. Family. Freedom. The issue is the surface. The value is the reason they care.
Arguing the issue feels productive. It comes with positions, talking points, and an unofficial scoreboard. It also tends to end exactly where my cousin and I used to end: two people, a little more certain and a little further apart.
Starting with a shared value changes the job of the conversation. The goal becomes understanding, and understanding is something you can both win. In my book, Clear and Compelling, a strategy called Name the Shared Interest turns a standoff into common ground. Politics is where it gets tested hardest.
Research in support
In 2009, psychologists Jesse Graham, Jonathan Haidt, and Brian Nosek published a study that is quietly hopeful. People across the spectrum draw on the same core set of moral values, including care, fairness, and loyalty. They weight them differently.
Haidt later added Liberty. Freedom matters across the spectrum, and it carries different pictures. One person hears freedom and thinks of being left alone. Another thinks of having a fair shot. Which is how my cousin and I could both stand on freedom and still land in different places.
Arguments framed in the listener's values land more effectively than arguments framed in the speaker's own. Your position can stay exactly where it is. The starting point is sharing that you understand where the other person stands.
Start with the value. The issue can wait.
Try this
Before your next political conversation, at work, online, or across the table, run two moves. First, separate facts from judgments. Write down one thing you believe about an issue. Circle the parts anyone could verify. Underline the parts that are your judgment. Second, name the value underneath the judgment, and open with it: "Let's start with what we agree on."
Free download: the Values Discovery Workbook
The same values exercise I walk executives through, now yours to keep.
A printable workbook to help you name your top values and what each one means to you. Get clear on yours before November 3, and the hard conversations get easier. Download free
What's one value you share with someone you disagree with?
The book
Salvatore Manzi coaches leaders, delivers keynotes, and wrote Clear and Compelling.
Communication strategies to help you lead with care and accountability
Order from Your Local Bookstore
@ClearandCompelling #ClearandCompelling